AFTER DARKBook One FREE→
← All guides

Gay Men's Sex Toy Guide: Exploring Solo & Together

By the FantasyBox Team · Updated

There's no right way to explore pleasure, and no checklist that comes with being a gay man. Some men are drawn to anal play, some aren't interested at all, and plenty sit somewhere in the middle depending on the day, the mood or the partner. Labels tell you very little about what you'll actually enjoy — your own curiosity tells you far more.

This guide is for single gay men and male couples who want clear, judgement-free advice: the main types of product, how to choose between them, how to stay safe and comfortable, and how to look after what you buy. It's written as general information, not medical advice — if something worries you, a GP or sexual health clinic is always the right call.

1. Choosing the right products for you

The best toy is the one that suits your body, your experience and the way you actually want to use it. Before you look at a single product, it helps to answer a few honest questions.

  • ◆Comfort: are you after something gentle and familiar, or ready to try a new sensation? There's no prize for starting big.
  • ◆Experience: if you're new to toys, simple and small beats clever and powerful. You can always build up.
  • ◆Intended use: solo, with a partner, or both? Some products are designed for one person; others are made to be shared or worn during sex.
  • ◆Materials: look for a clearly named non-porous material such as silicone, stainless steel, glass or hard ABS plastic, especially for anything internal.
  • ◆Preferences: texture, vibration, firmness and shape all feel different. Think about what you already enjoy and choose something that builds on it.

If you'd like a broader overview of every type of men's toy — including strokers and automatic toys in more depth — our honest buyer's guide to toys for men covers the wider category. Completely new to toys? Start with our first-timer's guide.

2. Popular types of male pleasure products

Most products fall into a handful of families. Here's how they differ, without the marketing gloss.

External stimulation products

Strokers, sleeves and handheld vibrators are designed for use on the penis. They're the most familiar starting point and a good way to learn which textures, pressures and intensities you like, alone or with a partner.

Vibrating rings

Worn at the base of the penis, a ring gently restricts blood flow out, which many men find helps with firmness and intensity. A vibrating version adds sensation for whoever is wearing it and for a partner close by. Start with a soft, stretchy silicone ring, and take it off after around 20–30 minutes or straight away if you feel numbness or discomfort.

Anal beads

A series of graduated beads on a flexible stem, usually with a ring or loop at the end for safe removal. Many men enjoy the sensation as each bead passes. Pick a single-piece silicone design rather than beads threaded on cord, which are hard to clean properly.

Prostate massagers

These are curved to reach the prostate, which sits a few centimetres inside, towards the front of the body. Prostate stimulation is about slow, steady pressure rather than speed, and some men find it intensely pleasurable while others feel very little — both are normal. Look for a curved design with a broad base or handle.

Anal-safe dildos

Not every dildo is suitable for anal use. Anal-safe designs have a wide, flared base or a suction cup large enough that the toy can't travel inside. Begin slim and smooth; texture and size are things to explore later, if at all.

Lubricants

Lubricant isn't an optional extra — the anus doesn't produce its own, and every internal product needs it. A good lube also makes external toys more comfortable and reduces friction on delicate skin. More on choosing one below.

Couples accessories

Rings, wearables, remote-controlled toys and products designed to be used together add something new to time with a partner. They're often chosen as much for the shared experience as the sensation itself.

3. Exploring on your own

Solo exploration is the lowest-pressure way to find out what you like. There's no one to impress, no need to explain anything, and you can stop, slow down or change your mind whenever you want.

  • ◆Privacy first: choose a time when you won't be interrupted. Feeling relaxed makes a bigger difference than any product feature.
  • ◆Keep expectations realistic: new sensations can take a few sessions to appreciate. A first try that feels 'just okay' isn't a failure.
  • ◆Beginner-friendly choices: a soft silicone ring, a simple stroker, or a small anal plug or slim massager with a flared base are all easy places to begin.
  • ◆Learn your preferences: notice what you enjoy — pressure, pace, vibration strength, position — and use that to guide your next purchase.
  • ◆Have everything ready: lube, a towel and somewhere to put the toy afterwards make the experience calmer and more comfortable.

4. Exploring with a male partner

Bringing toys into a relationship works best when it starts with a conversation, not a surprise. Talking about it is often half the fun.

  • ◆Communicate: share what you're curious about and ask what your partner would like to try. Make it easy for either of you to say 'not for me'.
  • ◆Agree boundaries: decide together what's on and off the table, and check in during play. Enthusiastic consent applies to toys just as much as to anything else.
  • ◆Find mutual preferences: choose something you're both genuinely interested in, rather than something only one of you wants.
  • ◆Hygiene: wash toys between partners or use a fresh condom on a shared toy each time it changes hands. Keep porous toys for one person only.
  • ◆Choose shared-use accessories: rings, wearables and remote-controlled toys are designed for couples, and non-porous materials are easiest to keep clean between you.

5. Anal toy safety for beginners

Anal play can be safe and very pleasurable when you follow a few simple rules. The key is choosing the right product and never rushing.

  • ◆Only use products designed for anal use, with a wide, flared base or a secure retrieval loop. The body can draw objects inward, and anything without a stopper can become stuck.
  • ◆Check the material and read the manufacturer's instructions before first use.
  • ◆Use plenty of compatible lubricant, and reapply whenever things start to feel dry. Water- or silicone-based lube is safe with latex condoms; oil-based is not.
  • ◆Start small and go gradually. Relax, breathe and never force insertion.
  • ◆Stop if something hurts. Discomfort is a signal to slow down or stop, not to push through.
  • ◆Clean products properly before and after every use.
  • ◆Use condoms on shared toys, changing them between partners, and never move a toy from anal to vaginal or oral use without washing it.
  • ◆Never use numbing creams or desensitising products. Pain is how your body tells you something is wrong — masking it raises the risk of injury.

For more on how we approach product safety and age checks, see our safety and trust page.

6. Materials, cleaning and storage

Material matters more than any feature, especially for anything used internally. Non-porous materials — 100% silicone, stainless steel, borosilicate glass and hard ABS plastic — have a sealed surface that can be cleaned thoroughly. Porous materials such as jelly rubber, PVC and many soft TPE blends have tiny pores that can trap bacteria, so they're best avoided for anal use and should never be shared.

Lubricant compatibility

  • ◆Water-based: works with every toy material and condom. The safest all-round choice; reapply as it dries.
  • ◆Silicone-based: lasts longer and stays slippery, but can damage silicone toys. Check the maker's advice or patch-test on the base first.
  • ◆Oil-based: weakens latex condoms, so avoid it whenever a condom is involved.
  • ◆Skip warming, tingling or heavily fragranced formulas at first, and never use anything designed to numb.

Cleaning, drying and storage

  • ◆Clean before first use and after every use with warm water and a mild, unscented soap or a dedicated toy cleaner, following the manufacturer's instructions.
  • ◆Keep water away from charging ports unless the toy is rated waterproof.
  • ◆Let toys dry completely before putting them away — trapped moisture encourages bacteria.
  • ◆Store toys separately in a pouch or their original box, so different materials don't react with each other.
  • ◆Retire anything that's torn, sticky or holds a smell after washing.

For step-by-step instructions by material, read our guide to cleaning and storing toys, and for help reading labels, our body-safe materials guide.

7. Is a mystery box right for you?

A mystery box swaps choosing for discovering. Instead of researching every product, you receive a curated selection and find out what's inside when you lift the lid.

The benefits

  • ◆Anticipation: the surprise is part of the experience, whether you're opening it alone or together.
  • ◆A way to try something new: you may enjoy products you'd never have picked for yourself.
  • ◆Less decision fatigue: someone else has done the curating.

The limitations

  • ◆You don't choose individual items, so you may receive something that isn't for you.
  • ◆If you have firm dislikes or very specific needs, choosing products individually may suit you better.

That's why it matters to understand what a box focuses on and who it's made for before you order. Our complete guide to mystery boxes explains how they work, and what's in the box shows how each FantasyBox experience differs.

8. Made for men. Driven by desire.

Discover VICE — The Gay Men's Mystery Box

VICE is a £59.99 mystery box created especially for gay men — whether you're exploring on your own or with another man. It focuses on male pleasure and includes anal-oriented accessories, chosen to bring the FantasyBox sense of anticipation to solo nights and shared ones.

Because of that focus, VICE isn't designed for vaginal play or for mixed-sex couples. If anal-focused products aren't your thing, you'll get more from Tease, Fever or Wild.

Plain, unbranded packaging · discreet billing · 18+

DISCOVER VICE & JOIN THE WAITLIST

9. Frequently asked questions

What are good first sex toys for gay men?

Start with whatever matches your curiosity rather than what you think you should own. A soft silicone stroker or stretchy ring is an easy external start. If you're curious about anal play, a small, smooth plug or slim massager with a flared base, plus a good lubricant, is a sensible first step.

Are anal toys suitable for beginners?

Yes, if they're designed for anal use and you take it slowly. Choose something small and smooth with a flared base or retrieval loop, use plenty of lubricant, relax, and stop if anything hurts. Size and intensity can come later.

What should I look for in a body-safe toy?

A clearly named non-porous material — 100% silicone, stainless steel, borosilicate glass or hard ABS plastic — a smooth, seamless finish that's easy to clean, and clear manufacturer care instructions. Be wary of vague labels and anything with a strong chemical smell.

Can couples share toys safely?

Yes, with care. Wash toys between partners, or put a fresh condom on a toy each time it passes between you. Porous materials can't be fully cleaned, so keep those for one person only. Regular sexual health check-ups are a good idea for anyone sharing toys.

Which lubricant should I choose?

Water-based lubricant works with every toy material and with condoms, so it's the safest default. Silicone-based lube lasts longer, which many people prefer for anal play, but it can damage silicone toys — check the toy maker's advice. Oil-based lube weakens latex condoms.

Do all gay men enjoy anal play?

No. Some men love it, some enjoy it occasionally, and plenty never do — none of that says anything about who you are. Pick products for what you actually enjoy, not what anyone assumes you should.

Is a mystery box suitable for beginners?

It can be, as long as you understand what kind of box you're buying. Read the description of who it's for and what it focuses on first. If you already know you have strong dislikes, a box you can choose item by item may suit you better.

What makes VICE different?

VICE is curated specifically for gay men — single men and male couples. It focuses on male pleasure and includes anal-oriented accessories, so it's not designed for vaginal play or mixed-sex couples. If anal-focused products aren't for you, Tease, Fever or Wild may be a better fit.

Explore at your own pace

Compare every FantasyBox experience, from first-time curiosity to something bolder.

Compare the boxes

CONTINUE EXPLORING